click the link below and direct registry today then money will flow into your account
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Trixie Angeles. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Trixie Angeles. Tampilkan semua postingan

Jumat, 13 Mei 2011

When TV journalists carry their press freedom too far


“Some of them are grossly uninformed, misleading, irresponsible, systematically manipulative, or downright wacky—and they are oftentimes expressed in uncivil, grammatically fractured, and convoluted language as well… ”



When TV journalists carry their press freedom too far

JOSE A. CARILLO

I know only too well that freedom of speech is a hallmark of a robust democracy, and we are most fortunate that our country’s mass media currently enjoy this freedom to a remarkably high degree. I must say, however, that some of our national TV networks have lately been carrying this freedom of expression too far. A case in point is their recent unbridled use of the online social media facilities of Facebook and Twitter to stream in raw, uninter-mediated opinions onscreen during TV programs or interviews on controversial topics.

Of course there’s value and virtue in getting a quick reading of the public pulse on matters of great importance, but I think it’s clear that whether expressed in English or whatever language, many of the opinions drawn in by those TV programs under these circumstances are highly unsuitable for broadcast. Some of them are grossly uninformed, misleading, irresponsible, systematically manipulative, or downright wacky—and they are oftentimes expressed in uncivil, grammatically fractured, and convoluted language as well. This was particularly true in the case of some vitriolic and inflammatory tweets for and against the Reproductive Health Bill shown in recent televised debates or guest shows. There’s no doubt in my mind that because of the very hostile and uncivil character of many such postings or tweets, by no means could they ever be an accurate and reliable measure of public opinion. (I remember that in the early days of TV broadcasting, a sharp mind in the US media—if I remember right, he was Walter Lippmann—sagely observed that one of the serious drawbacks of broadcast TV is its power to widely disseminate and in the process inadvertently validate uninformed opinion.)

So, in the same way that the print media are able to routinely edit the opinions they print on their pages, couldn’t the TV programs at least find some way of intermediating all that instant Facebook and Twitter feedback to ensure that only clear, sensible, and responsible ones—no matter how contrarian or strongly worded—are streamed onscreen? I think it would greatly raise the quality of public discourse if the broadcast media can do this.

The other matter I’d like to take up here is the lack of basic courtesy and decorum among some TV investigative journalists when they do face-to-face or telephone interviews in the course of their TV programs. These investigative journalists, live and onscreen, have this tendency to needle and browbeat their respondents to admit culpability in a supposed crime or misdeed that they (the investigative journalists) are working to establish within the short time frame of the TV program itself.

But really now, even if guilty or rotten to the core, who in his right mind would admit culpability on TV for all the world to see and hear? And isn’t it axiomatic that in our democratic society, the accused is entitled to due process and is presumed innocent until proven guilty? I’m afraid that these niceties are lost to some of these investigative journalists. In one such TV program I watched recently, in fact, the investigative journalist acted and used language that made it unmistakable that he thought himself the arresting police officer, prosecutor, legal counsel, judge, and executioner all rolled into one.

TV broadcasting being strongly imbued with public interest, I think the national TV networks should reconsider their live streaming of raw, unmitigated feedback from the social media, and their TV news reporters and talk-show hosts should closely watch their behavior and language on camera and not allow their personal biases and political leanings to get the better of them.

They should keep themselves objective, fair, and civil when exercising their press freedom. This way, they can maintain not only their own credibility and integrity as sources of information but also the viability of the mass media as a democratic institution.

Selasa, 28 Desember 2010

TV News: Popularity Is Not Credibility

"credibility from its source..?"

“Well, projecting credibility seems to be a big deal for TV news. I wonder though if this personality-centered approach would help correct the perception that TV news is the most stupid among the three traditional news media sources (TV, radio, print)... Of course, none of these crazy antics can compare to the ultimate fakery of all: Some news anchors don’t really know what they’re talking about. Not surprising since, with the exception of at least one, most of these anchors are just pretty faces who also happen to know how to project credibility while reading from a teleprompter...”

TV News: Popularity Is Not Credibility

by Betterphilippines Getreal

There’s a long-standing practice in local TV that I find disturbing. I’m talking about the personality-centered approach to promoting TV news.

I’m convinced that this is the wrong approach if the intention is to get more people to watch the news or to boost their news programs’ credibility. The way I understand it credibility is a result of consistent and excellent work. It’s not the other way around.

Maybe I’m wrong. Maybe the local TV networks are not really after credibility. Maybe the target is just popularity. That makes sense after all most people here seem to equate popularity with credibility. Just consider the fact that in Philippine-style elections the most popular almost always wins.

So what’s the problem with using the personality-approach in promoting the news? For one, it smacks of show business, which is something this country doesn’t need more of. Giving the public more personalities to ogle at won’t do anyone any good. What they need — even if they may not necessarily want it — is better information.

Speaking of show business, it should be pointed out that there’s a lot of showbiz fakery going on in TV news. Here’s a classic from overseas.

This sort of thing also happens here. Next time there’s a live TV report about a big storm, take note of the reporter’s appearance. He/she will most likely be dripping wet. Keep an eye out too for the news anchors in the studio. Some of them like to wear rain clothes on such occasions as if there’s also rain inside the studio.

Of course, none of these crazy antics can compare to the ultimate fakery of all: Some news anchors don’t really know what they’re talking about. Not surprising since, with the exception of at least one, most of these anchors are just pretty faces who also happen to know how to project credibility while reading from a teleprompter.

Well, projecting credibility seems to be a big deal for TV news. I wonder though if this personality-centered approach would help correct the perception that TV news is the most stupid among the three traditional news media sources (TV, radio, print).


In case you’re wondering, here are the most common points against TV news:
(from: http://www.abacon.com/stovall/lecture09presentation/sld003.htm)


1. too short, too shallow
2. pictures drive a story
3. superficial over substance
4. clichés in writing, reporting



Now let’s take a look at each one.
Too Short, Too Shallow

In this regard, the problem really is the medium. The average TV news report runs from about 1 minute and 30 seconds to 2 minutes. Seriously, can anyone really provide substantial reporting with such a limitation?



Pictures drive a story
It’s bad enough that TV news is driven by pictures or video to be exact, but now much of that video highlights not the story but the reporter. Making oneself the story seems to be the in-thing nowadays among TV reporters.



Superficial over substance
I suspect at some point in TV news history someone said, “Hey, it’s called an idiot box anyway so we might as well make our reports idiotic.”
But seriously, consider the fact that in TV news the structure of the reports are based on what is called “dramatic unity.”

(from: http://www.ablongman.com/stovall6e/chp07/chp07.html)
Dramatic unity — The most common story structure for the broadcast news story is dramatic unity with its three parts: climax, cause and effect. Students should also understand the importance of an attention-getting lead in making sure that listeners hear and understand their stories. Such leads require a deft touch on the part of the writer. They may look easy to produce at first glance, but they are more difficult to do well than they appear.


The problem with this is that the most dramatic detail isn’t always the most important.

Cliches in writing, reporting
This one’s pretty obvious. Just listen to the closing sentences of TV news reports. One sports news reporter is particularly notorious in this regard. In most of his reports on Manny Pacquiao’s boxing matches he always says something like, “ngunit ang pinakamatinding sandata ni Manny ay ang kanyang puso.”
I asked a friend who used to work in the TV news industry what she thinks of the observation that TV news is the most stupid. Surprisingly, she said it’s true. She even sent me an email enumerating some reasons she says contribute to the stupidity.
thought i’d share this…



local tv news is stupid. allow me to enumerate some reasons:
1. in general people who apply for tv news on-cam work do so not because they want to be serious journalists. they just want to see their faces on tv and hopefully become famous. that is their main motivation.


2. most people who apply for the position of tv reporter have mass comm or other related degrees. writing and other “journalistic” skills are not at all honed in such courses given their generalized scope. it is not unusual to see a newbie tv reporter being deployed to cover complicated senate session or court hearings.


3. very little “writing” discipline is observed in tv news. grammar rules even in tagalog newscasts are practically ignored. this can be attributed to the fact that most script editors do not even bother to review the rules before they unleash their “editing” prowess on the reports submitted to them. this lack of “writing” discipline in the TV newsroom leads to the propagation of wrong writing rules invented by script editors who haven’t even heard of a dangling modifier.


4. in tv news, soundbyte is king. this antiquated rule forces the whole tv news production team to use short, keyword-centric phrases from their interviews. unfortunately, such phrases are usually just motherhood statements.



Interestingly, a recent study shows a link between a popular TV news source and misinformation in the United States.
(frm http://www.alternet.org/story/149193/study_confirms_that_fox_news_makes_you_stupid/)
Yet another study has been released proving that watching Fox News is detrimental to your intelligence. World Public Opinion, a project managed by the Program on International Policy Attitudes at the University of Maryland, conducted a survey of American voters that shows that Fox News viewers are significantly more misinformed than consumers of news from other sources. What’s more, the study shows that greater exposure to Fox News increases misinformation.


You can find the full survey report here.

So what’s the point of this rant? I have only two major points to make. The first one I address to the bigshots running the various TV news departments. If you really want to provide public service through information, please do better work. Focus on improving your output not on turning your reporters and news anchors into celebrities.

My second point is for the viewers. Don’t rely too much on TV news for information. Make sure to get additional information from other sources and use critical thinking in analyzing what you see and hear.

Actually, there’s a third point and it’s for both the TV news people and the viewing public.